THERE were splits in Labour over Alister Jack’s decision to block the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform Bill.
In Holyrood, Monica Lennon described it as a “cynical and dangerous power move by an out of control UK government.”
However, in the Commons, the Labour MP Rosie Duffield welcomed the invoking of the Section 35 order, saying the law passed by MSPs “clearly conflicts with the Equality Act and would have repercussions for women across the UK.”
In last month’s debate and vote on the legislation, 18 of Labour’s 22 MSPs backed the change in law, with two voting against and two others not voting.
The Bill simplifies the process for obtaining a gender recognition certificate, by removing the need for a gender dysphoria diagnosis, and cutting back on the amount of time a trans person needs to live in their acquired gender.
It also changes the age at which a trans person can apply for a GRC from 18 to 16.
Over the weekend, Sir Keir Starmer said he had concerns about some of the changes, particularly the drop in age limit.
He told the BBC: “I have concerns about the provision in Scotland, in particular the age reduction to 16 and in particular the rejection of our amendment in relation to the Equalities Act.”
When asked whether he would block the Scottish legislation if he was prime minister. He said he wanted to wait to see what legal advice the UK Government had received.
READ MORE: Keir Starmer showing ‘utter contempt’ for Labour MSPs over gender laws
Speaking to the Daily Record, Ms Lennon, said she was “disappointed” with the party leader’s comments.
She said: “The Bill was also supported by the Labour group of MSPs, who supported lowering the age threshold from 18 to 16. His comments have undermined Scottish Labour and are unhelpful in terms of the wider debate on equalities.”
Her Holyrood colleague Paul Sweeney disagreed.
“I don’t think we feel undermined,” he told The Herald. “I think we feel undermined by the UK Government, first and foremost.”
He said: “We’ve had conversations with colleagues. I’m working with MPs and we’re trying to get ourselves into a place where they understand what is a fast-moving issue. I guess not everyone’s been across this matter.
“I think the fundamental that we need to recognise is that the matter for deciding the merits of the gender recognition reform here in Scotland is for MSPs.
“The issue here that we need support from everyone who supports devolution is on this principle that a Section 35 is an overreach and should not have been used.”
READ MORE: Nicola Sturgeon confirms judicial review bid over gender reforms veto
In the Commons, following Mr Jack’s statement, Ms Duffield, who has long been critical of changes to the GRA, said that the Scottish legislation would “allow anyone at all to legally self-identify as either sex and therefore enter all spaces, including those necessarily segregated by sex, such as domestic violence settings, changing rooms and prisons.”
She was heckled by colleague Ben Bradshaw who described the claim as “absolute rubbish.”
Ms Duffield said on Twitter afterwards: “Being shouted down in the Chamber by @UKLabour men who clearly don’t want women to speak up for our rights to single sex spaces. How very progressive.
“Should probably point out that the SNP men were also yelling, but I expected that of course.”
READ MORE: Shona Robison: ‘Tory Section 35 order a dark day for trans rights’
Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi, a shadow Northern Ireland minister, accused Nicola Sturgeon of using women as “pawns” in her “constitutional game playing”.
The party’s Shadow Scotland secretary Ian Murray said the legislation had “turned into a constitutional bun fight.”
In Holyrood, Ms Lennon told MSPs the Bill was about “dignity, fairness and equality for a marginalised group of trans citizens.”
“The Secretary of State may hide behind legal advice, but the truth is, the Tories at Westminster have proven that they are no offence to trans people, and as the architects of the rape clause, we know they are no friends to women and girls.”
This was “a cynical and dangerous power move by an out of control UK government’s determined to wreck this bill at any costs,” she added.
In Wales, the Labour First Minister suggested his ministers would support the Scottish government if the matter ends up in the Supreme Court.
He told members of the Senedd: The UK government’s decision to use powers that have never been used in the history of devolution is a very dangerous moment.”
“I agree with the First Minister of Scotland that this could be a very slippery slope indeed.”
Denial of responsibility! Planetcirculate is an automatic aggregator around the global media. All the content are available free on Internet. We have just arranged it in one platform for educational purpose only. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials on our website, please contact us by email – [email protected]. The content will be deleted within 24 hours.